OMAS Extra Lucens and Lucens Fountain Pen Review

Top to bottom: OMAS Extra Lucens, OMAS Extra Lucens, OMAS Lucens
Top to bottom: OMAS Extra Lucens, OMAS Extra Lucens, OMAS Lucens

The Lucens and Extra Lucens were the best quality and best looking Italian pens of the 1930s and 1940s.

Italian pens during this period were largely inspired (and in many cases copies) of American pens. The Lucens and Extra Lucens were offered with visulated barrels much like the Parker Vacumatic and Waterman Ink View. The Extra Lucens also featured an arrow nib and an arrow clip not unlike the one found on the Parker Vacumatic.

In the late 1930s Wahl Eversharp came out with the Doric, a faceted pen very similar to the Extra Lucens; there is some debate about which pen was introduced first.

Omas Extra Lucens -2

 

The bodies were made of celluloid and all of them had a degree of transparency to them.  The pens in my photos that appear black (because they are filled with ink) have black striped barrels and were originally clear but have turned into to a red color.  There were a number of beautiful celluloids that these pens were produced in.  The rarest and most valuable color was a grey pearl (if you Google “OMAS Extra Lucens Limited Edition” you can see a reproduction of this pen, though the original was not brown).

Both the Lucens and Extra Lucens use a stantuffo tuffante, or plunger filling system. This system is considered to be the same as the one used by the American brand Dunn, which had a patent on this system in 1920. OMAS patented their version in 1936 and for this reason we see “Brev.73725 – 1936” on the barrels of these pens.

Omas Extra Lucens -4

The plunger filler eliminated the use of sacs which made for a (supposedly) more durable filling system with a larger ink capacity.

Omas Extra Lucens -9

Personally, I do not like this system and I am not surprised that it was abandoned in favor of the piston filler. Filling the pen requires pulling out the plunger which draws up ink into the pen and then quickly pushing the plunger back down allowing the air to escape through a breather tube inside the barrel…if you push the plunger down too slowly all of the ink you just drew into the pen will be expelled. The filling system is relatively durable such that I feel comfortable using these pens every day. The weak points being a cork seal and breather tube.

The Lucens and Extra Lucens came in three sizes, the largest of the three measures about 14cm long capped and the midsize measures about 13cm (unfortunately I don’t have a small one to measure). The larger model is more or less the same size as the current all celluloid OMAS Paragon. The midsize is very similar in feel to a Pelikan M400 though slightly longer.

Top to bottom: OMAS Extra Lucens (large), OMAS Extra Lucens (small), OMAS Lucens (small)
Top to bottom: OMAS Extra Lucens (large), OMAS Extra Lucens (midsize), OMAS Lucens (midsize)

The nibs of the Lucens and Extra Lucens are quite different. The Lucens “Extra” nib with heart shape breather hole was the standard nib used on all of the OMAS Extra pens, while the Extra Lucens had a special arrow nib with a pentagon shape breather hole.

OMAS Extra nib
OMAS Extra nib
OMAS Extra Lucens nib
OMAS Extra Lucens nib

The Extra nib has longer tines than the Extra Lucens nibs creating more flexibility. The Extra Lucens nibs are soft and springing but not flexible (based on the small handful I have sampled).

Two Extra Lucens nibs
Two Extra Lucens nibs

During the war the Lucens and Extra Lucens pens had white metal trim and “permanio” nibs which were made of a steel alloy. These nibs, unlike Montblanc and Aurora’s wartime nibs, were not very resistant and many of them corroded.

The ebonite feed is much like those found on current production OMAS pens
The ebonite feed is much like those found on current production OMAS pens

The Extra Lucens was also offered with a bi-tone reversible arrow nib. The reverse side was stiff for carbon copies while right-side up the nib was soft like a regular OMAS nib.

Omas Extra Lucens -10
Writing sample with the Lucens

These pens are very nice reliable writers that I enjoy using. I almost always have one inked up. Like most vintage Italian pens, these are relatively rare and expensive. The large size Extra Lucens are the most desirable but for me as writers I prefer to use the smaller models.

Advertisements

OMAS Paragon Fountain Pen Review

 

Pen Shaming- "BAD PEN!"
Pen Shaming

This pen is troublemaker.  I have had it for a good number of years and as I reflect on it now, I am not exactly sure why.

I figure that my first OMAS review should be one that I would consider to be a great first OMAS.  Don’t take that to mean that the Paragon is the bottom of the line pen, it’s not, it is in fact the top of line oversized model but used, in black resin, it is quite affordable and a good place to start with the brand if you are willing to roll the dice a bit.

OMAS Paragon

A little background:

For those that do not know, OMAS stands forOfficina Meccanica Armondo Simoni” and they continue to make some of the world’s most beautiful fountain pens.  OMAS is famous for their Arte Italiana line that features wonderful faceted pens.  The Paragon is the largest model (and consequently the most desirable) in the Arte Italiana line.

OMAS Paragon
Barrel Imprints can help identify the approximate age of a Paragon.

The Paragon I am reviewing today is from the early 1990s.  It differs in a few ways from the current Arte Italiana Paragon which confusingly now has two distinct styles “Vintage” and “Icon”.  The “Vintage” style is more or less the same pen they have been making for decades and most closely resembles my 1990s Paragon.

 

Appearance

OMAS Paragon

The body is made out of black resin and has 12 facets with 18kt gold furniture including Greek key bands on the cap and on the section just above the threading.  The pen terminates at each end with short points.  The large nib is a classic OMAS arrow design that I have seen on OMAS pens as old as the 1930s.   It is one of the best looking nib designs out there.

OMAS Paragon

No ifs, ands, or buts about it, this pen is beautiful.  I have had the pleasure of owning a few celluloid versions and those really gave my Nakaya a run for its money in the awe department.

Score: 4/5

 

Build Quality

OMAS pens are turned from a single block of resin or celluloid and just about everything on this pen is done by hand.  OMAS made the nib in house and it’s beautiful.  Even the hand cut ebonite feed is beautiful.  There are no seams and nothing on this pen looks poorly executed BUT there are some functional problems.

Hand cut ebonite feed.
Hand cut ebonite feed.

The piston knob is hard to turn (something I have experienced with all my OMAS pens from the 1980s-2000s purchased new and used).   I don’t know if OMAS is trying to cut down on costs by saving on lubricators or what but it seems odd that such an expensive brand would have a hard and rough mechanism.

My biggest gripe about this pen is that I get ink all over my fingers when I use it.  I believe ink comes out from the nib sleeve and onto the collar of the section.  I have sent this pen in for repair where the entire pen was disassembled (piston mechanism lubricated…still hard to twist) and the problem wasn’t solved.

This is a beautifully made pen but unfortunately, it just doesn’t work all that well.

Score: 2.5/5

 

Size & Weight

OMAS Paragon

The Paragon measures 5.6” capped, 5.25” uncapped and a whopping 7.15” posted.  My partially full Paragon weighs in at 19.6 grams, which is very comfortable, and lightweight for a pen of this size.   I find that the Paragon is comfortable to write with unposted as well as posted, despite its long length.

For me the combination of its large size and lightweight make it almost perfect.  I am buying more and more old OMAS pens from the 40s and 50s and I always try to opt for the largest size in a series.

I did not realize until after I took the picture that the OMAS pictured beside the Montblanc 149 isn't the 1990s Paragon in all the other pictures...its an older 1960s celluloid version.  The size is identical though.
I did not realize until after I took the picture that the OMAS pictured beside the Montblanc 149 isn’t the 1990s Paragon in all the other pictures…its an older 1960s celluloid version. The size is identical though.

Founder Armondo Simoni, believed that writing should be an enjoyable experience and as such pens needed to be lightweight.  You wont see any overweight OMAS pens until after he passed in 1958.

Interestingly, the Paragon size (also know by the number 557) has changed throughout the years.  In the late 40s to early 50s the 557 was over 5.6” and then in the late 50s it dropped to under 5.5” which would have been the senior size (aka the 556) in the late 40s early 50s.   Today the Paragon is back to its original extra large size.

 Score: 4/5

 

Performance

Up until the mid 1990s OMAS manufactured their own nibs in house before switching over to highly modified Bock nibs.   It is clear to me now having owned a several modern OMAS pens with both Bock and OMAS nibs that the change was really quite minor in terms of performance and feel.  They both have the same hand cut ebonite feed and the design is mostly the same.  In the 1960s and prior the OMAS made some of the best “semi-flex” (like the 14kt Extra Lucens pictured below) and flex nibs that I have ever used.  Below are three different nibs from Paragon-sized OMAS pens.

Left to right: 1) Bock made 18kt gold, 2) OMAS made 18kt gold, 3) OMAS made 14kt gold "Extra Lucens" from the 1960s
Left to right: 1) Bock made 18kt gold, 2) OMAS made 18kt gold, 3) OMAS made 14kt gold “Extra Lucens” from the 1960s.  “OMAS” on a Bock nib has a large “O” and a bit different Greek-style lettering.  You cannot see it without removing the nibs but the OMAS made nibs actually have a much longer body than the Bock ones.  I don’t think there is any difference from a performance perspective but it is clear that OMAS made nibs are made with more gold.

The medium point 18kt gold nib is quite springy and with its generous flow feels quite nice on paper.  The nib as long as I have had it skips.  I sent it to a well-known nibmeister to be sorted out unfortunately he didn’t fix the problem, it still skips…I suspect that it needs a bit more regrinding.  If the nib didn’t skip it would be one of my best nibs on a modern pen…it really feels excellent.

Side view of the Paragon nib.
Side view of the Paragon nib.

In the end it sort of does everything I don’t want a fountain pen to do… it skips and gets ink on my fingers.

Score: 1.5/5

 

Filling System

The Paragon is a piston-filler and holds a good amount of ink.  If you have ever had the displeasure of twisting the piston knob on an “untested” vintage pen only to find that ink has dried inside the pen locking the mechanism then you have a pretty good idea of what it’s like to use the piston on this pen (and sadly most modern OMAS fountain pens).  I might be exaggerating a bit but let’s just say it’s not that pleasant.

Score: 1.5/5

 

Value

A used resin OMAS Paragon in nice condition can be had for around $200-$250 and honestly it’s a ton of pen for the money IF you get one that works well.  My success rate with both new and used OMAS pens from 1980-2005 has been about 60% and I have had more fountain pens from OMAS than any other manufacturer.

I know people who have had nothing but great luck with modern OMAS pens so I would encourage any potential buyer to do their own homework and come to their own conclusions.

New, you can buy a resin Paragon (or some version of it) for around $600-$700.  The beautiful celluloid versions cost around $1,000.

Score: 2.5/5

 

OMAS Paragon

 

Bottom Line

This Paragon’s beautiful looks are let down by poor performance.

Final Score 16/30

Here some great reviews of the OMAS Paragon:

(I have no affiliation to the sites linked below)

The Noble Savage – OMAS Paragon Blu Venezia 2003

These Beautiful Pens – Amazing Celluloid: Omas Paragon Arco